Primo Too Pizzeria Amherst

Overview

Primo Too Pizzeria Amherst is a local gem that perfectly blends delicious food with a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Located at 2144 255 Triangle St, Amherst, MA 01002, this pizzeria has been serving the community with mouthwatering pizzas and a diverse menu that keeps guests coming back time and time again.

Walking into Primo Too, you're greeted by a warm ambiance that makes it feel like home. The scent of freshly baked dough and sizzling toppings fills the air, creating an immediate sense of comfort and anticipation. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick bite to-go, the restaurant’s vibe is always welcoming.

The menu at Primo Too is a delightful mix of classic pizzeria favorites and unique twists on traditional dishes. The pizza is the star of the show here, with each slice packed with flavor. The crust strikes the perfect balance-crispy on the edges while soft and chewy inside. It's the ideal foundation for their variety of toppings, from the timeless pepperoni to more adventurous options like roasted vegetables and specialty cheeses. One of their standout creations is the Primo Special pizza, a combination of savory meats and fresh vegetables that never disappoints. The sauce is rich and flavorful, perfectly complementing the cheese and toppings without overpowering them.

In addition to their pizza, the menu includes a variety of pastas, subs, and salads. The baked ziti is a local favorite-rich, cheesy, and comforting, it’s the kind of dish that feels like a warm hug on a chilly day. For those looking to enjoy something lighter, their house salad, topped with a tangy vinaigrette, offers a refreshing balance to the heavier pizza and pasta options.

What sets Primo Too apart from other pizzerias in the area is the quality of their ingredients. They source the freshest vegetables, meats, and cheeses, ensuring every dish is as flavorful as possible. The kitchen staff takes great pride in crafting each meal to perfection, making sure that every bite is something special. In fact, you can often find regulars praising the consistency of the food-it's always just as good as the last time.

The staff at Primo Too are another reason why this place feels so welcoming. From the moment you walk in, you're treated like family. The servers are attentive without being overbearing, and they’re always happy to recommend dishes or accommodate special requests. The owners, too, are often present, making sure everything runs smoothly and that customers are happy with their experience.

Another highlight of dining at Primo Too is the convenience. Located in the heart of Amherst, it’s an ideal spot for a casual lunch or dinner. Whether you’re a student at the nearby University of Massachusetts or a local resident, the restaurant is easy to get to, with plenty of parking available. Their takeout service is also quick, ensuring you can enjoy your meal wherever you are.

If you’re in the area and craving some great food, Primo Too Pizzeria Amherst is definitely worth a visit. The combination of delicious pizza, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a standout in the Amherst dining scene. It’s clear why so many people keep coming back for more, and it’s easy to see why this pizzeria has earned its place as one of the best spots in town. Whether you're dining in with friends or grabbing a pizza to go, Primo Too delivers a memorable experience every time.

Good to know

Service options

βœ“ Outdoor seating βœ“ Kerbside pickup βœ“ Delivery βœ“ On-site services βœ“ Takeaway βœ“ Dine-in

Highlights

βœ“ Fast service

Popular for

βœ“ Lunch βœ“ Dinner βœ“ Solo dining

Accessibility

βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible car park βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible seating βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

βœ“ Alcohol βœ“ All you can eat βœ“ Beer βœ“ Braille menu βœ“ Cocktails βœ“ Coffee βœ“ Comfort food βœ“ Halal food βœ“ Happy-hour drinks βœ“ Happy-hour food βœ“ Late-night food βœ“ Organic dishes βœ“ Private dining room βœ“ Quick bite βœ“ Salad bar βœ“ Small plates βœ“ Spirits βœ“ Vegan options βœ“ Vegetarian options βœ“ Wine

Dining options

βœ“ Lunch βœ“ Dinner βœ“ Dessert βœ“ Seating βœ“ Table service

Amenities

βœ“ Toilet

Atmosphere

βœ“ Casual

Crowd

βœ“ Groups βœ“ Tourists βœ“ University students

Planning

βœ“ Accepts reservations

Payments

βœ“ Cheques βœ“ Credit cards βœ“ Debit cards βœ“ NFC mobile payments βœ“ Credit cards

Children

βœ“ Good for kids βœ“ High chairs

Parking

βœ“ Free of charge street parking βœ“ Free parking lot βœ“ Parking

Photos

Location

Reviews

- No ratings yet 339 reviews
Amazing 210
Great 69
Okay 30
Not Great 12
Terrible 30
Haille Brooks

My boyfriend recommended this place for dinner one night because he’s been many times and loves it and I see why !! I have ordered this same grilled chicken caesar salad three times in the past two weeks because it’s TRULY the best salad I’ve ever had. I’m not completely sure but I’m gonna guess the dressing is house made because it’s phenomenal !! The fresh lemon is a great touch ! I like salad but I usually never LOVE salad. I’m absolutely obsessed !!! I would eat it every single day if I could. We also always get a pizza and I’ve had the pasta before too, all of which are fantastic as well ! Great quality food, super quick service and the employees are extremely kind :) This is my new favorite takeout spot ever !! (Sorry for the not so great quality image, I was WAY too excited to eat the salad to take a better pic lol)

Dannuel Rivera

not a bad spot at all, prices for slices are not crazy expensive and the slice portions they give out are pretty good and filling. The grinders they got arent bad at all either! chicken bacon ranch is bomb

Miranda Bushey

I lived in New York prior to moving to western mass and have been pizza deprived since until I discovered Primo. They have big slices with amazing toppings and don't rip you off. My favorite slice is #13 the 'salad slice' with added pesto. Also, love the veggie burrito that comes with homemade salsa. Super friendly staff too. People are always laughing and having a good time. It's clear they love what they do because the food shows. Happy people and good food go hand in hand.

Amy McPherson

This place has great pizza and subs, I love their Italian sub especially. Conveniently located. Good service great food at good prices. I highly recommend primo too pizzeria

Theo

Best piece of pizza in my life, bread perfectly thin and crisp, some of the most respectful workers and an amazing pizzeria aesthetic inside.

Ani Torres

The pizza was very yummy! My kids usually don’t like pepperoni, but they ate most of the pepperoni in this pizza lol

Write a review